top of page
WORK_50.jpg

Limits, restrictions and exceptions: How home insurers cut your coverage

6 minutes ago
25 min read

An exclusive analysis of thousands of insurance policy documents

reveals the state-approved changes that protect companies and cost

homeowners.


By David Fleshler

South Florida Sun Sentinel


For Jay Pastorius, the worst part wasn’t the discovery that his water heater ha exploded.


Or that the interior of his Islamorada home had so thoroughly soaked up moisture from that catastrophe that he could put his hand through the walls.


The worst arrived when the desk adjuster at Florida Family Insurance notified him that his coverage topped out at $10,000, due to a cap on water damage payments that has become standard in Florida in recent years. As a general contractor, Pastorius estimated that repairs would cost more than $70,000.


“How could they possibly call it indemnity or peace of mind when they clearly aren’t giving you a way to cover the damages?” he asked. “I’m not really criticizing the insurance companies. I’m criticizing the politicians who are supposed to be protecting the people. They’re not protecting the people.”


During debates about the cost and availability of homeowners insurance in Florida, a

crucial point is often ignored: Many insurance policies are just plain worse for homeowners than they used to be.


They cap payments for damages. They make it more difficult to challenge your insurer if there’s a disagreement. And they give insurers an array of options to limit or even deny claims altogether.


With the assent of state regulators, insurance companies have imposed a growing list of limitations on coverage over the past decade, forcing homeowners to pay for restoration work themselves or just learn to live with the damage. At the same time, the industry has succeeded on a second front, persuading the Florida Legislature in 2022 and 2023 to enact a sweeping series of laws favoring insurance companies. As they advocated each set of changes, insurers insisted the moves would help rein in premiums and coax more competition into the state’s market.


Today, the market has improved, with new companies opening shop in Florida, more

options for homeowners and companies announcing rate cuts. But despite this more favorable climate, many restrictions remain on coverage for roofs, water damage, hurricanes and other hazards, leaving policyholders with weaker coverage they may not understand — until too late.


For the latest installment of Uncovered, an investigation of Florida’s property insurance market, the Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel, with the support of the University of Maryland’s Howard Center for Investigative Journalism, set out to assess those developments.


A team of journalists analyzed thousands of documents that track the interactions between insurance companies and the state’s Office of Insurance Regulation, as well as hundreds of homeowners' policies obtained through searches of lawsuits. The news organizations also conducted a survey of the state’s public adjusters, who represent homeowners in their dealings with insurance companies, to understand the impact of some of the most significant new policy limitations.


The analysis focused on a dozen of the companies with the most Florida customers, but the limitations found in their policies have become widespread in the industry, attorneys and advocates say.


Here are some of the major changes that took effect over the last 10 years.

Water damage: Seven of the 12 companies cap payments for burst pipes and other internal water problems at $10,000 for some or all of their policies, a sum that’s often tens of thousands of dollars short of the actual damage. This is a critical limitation because such water damage is considered the most important non-hurricane cause of Florida homeowners’ insurance claims.


Matching repairs: Seven companies set a strict limit on payments for cosmetic work that ensures repaired areas of floor, roof or cabinets match undamaged areas. They cap the payments at 1% of the insured value of the property, often far short of what’s needed.


Appraisal: Five companies restrict the homeowner’s ability to obtain an independent

appraisal that can be used to help set the amount the company pays if there’s a dispute over the value of the damaged property.


Roofs: Four companies adopted tight language excluding payments for roof damage if they can attribute it to wear, age or deterioration. And nine offer a reduced premium to persuade policyholders to accept less compensation for roof replacement as the roof ages.


In addition to policy changes approved by state regulators, which can vary from company to company, the Florida Legislature also stepped in to limit insurance coverage. The Legislature cut the time to report a claim from three years to one year, allowed companies to eliminate the lowest hurricane deductibles on homes insured for at least $1 million and took several steps to make it more difficult to use lawyers to dispute claims.


“Most homeowners have no idea their policies now contain endorsements that materially reduce coverage until they suffer a loss,” said Steven Bush, a Jacksonville lawyer who represents homeowners. “In many respects, the product they’re buying today is not the same product they were buying just a few years ago and costs more money.”


The insurance industry defends these limits as necessary for companies to provide

affordable policies to millions of homeowners.


“Coverage changes in Florida over time did not occur in a vacuum,” said Karen Collins, vice president of personal lines of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association, in a statement.


“They reflect lessons learned from hurricanes, claims and roofing fraud, legal system

abuse, and the impact of significant inflationary cost pressures in recent years. The overarching objective has been to protect long-term market stability in one of the most catastrophe prone states and preserve consumer choice.”


Shiloh Elliott, a spokesperson for the Office of Insurance Regulation, minimized her

agency’s role in the changes.


“When you look at the policy provisions you flagged, most of them are either long-standing features in the market or are directly shaped by Florida statutes,” she said in an email.


Once Pastorius found out about the $10,000 limit on water coverage for his Islamorada home, he called his insurance agent. As he tells it, this discussion took place:


“Oh yeah, Jay,” his agent said, “this year they changed that. It was in your renewal.”


“I said, ‘Well, you guys didn’t tell me about that. That’s a massive change in insurance

policy. How could you change that without bringing it to my attention?’ ”


It was in the cover letter for your renewal, the agent pointed out.


“I guess it was in the cover letter,” Pastorius said later. “But it certainly wasn’t in red bold. It wasn’t big. It was just ‘Oh, by the way, you got a water limitation.’ They should have said, ‘Hey, knucklehead, you need to know this.’ Because I would not have accepted it.”


As in his case, these changes often pass unnoticed for policy holders until a pipe leaks or a hurricane strikes.


“I get the calls from the single mom with two kids who’s working two jobs just to keep the bills paid, and the insurance company’s not wanting to pay her, and she doesn’t know what to do,” said Bush, the Jacksonville lawyer. “She didn’t have the money to fix that house, but she’s got two little kids running around with electrical live wires and tore-up floors.


“I get the call from the widow whose husband died six months before the storm, and he handled everything, and she has no clue about nothing, and she doesn’t know what to do, and she’s sitting there worrying herself to death because she thought she was safe, they paid off their house, they had insurance, thought it would cover it.”


‘The cap on water damage is ridiculously low’


A decade ago, Florida’s insurance market was in crisis.


Companies were fleeing. Homeowners were suing their insurance companies in staggering numbers, egged on, the industry said, by opportunistic law firms that had automated the business of taking the companies to court.


Roofing companies roamed Florida’s neighborhoods, persuading homeowners they could get brand-new roofs if their workers could go up on a ladder and detect enough storm damage. Unscrupulous contractors took advantage of burst pipes and leaky sinks to pad bills with unnecessary repairs, as insurers described it.


It all led to fraud, they said. And one of the biggest sources they cited was a standard practice in which the homeowner signed away all their insurance benefits to a contractor who was allowed by law to pursue claims on their behalf, even filing lawsuits in their name.


Known as “assignment of benefits,” the practice persisted in Florida for years despite the industry’s pleas to the Legislature to ban it, with allies of the state’s trial lawyers helping to block it in the Senate.


Whatever its contribution to fraud, assignment-of-benefits was used by insurance

companies to justify one of the most important limits on coverage for Florida homeowners: The $10,000 cap on water damage payments.


During a conference call with stock analysts in late 2016, the chief executive of Heritage Insurance Holdings asserted the connection.


The $10,000 limit would diminish the financial incentive to inflate claims, which the

industry blamed on contractors who obtained assigned benefits, primarily in South Florida, then-CEO Bruce Lucas said.


“That helps us to curb additional rate increases on innocent policyholders that would

otherwise get a rate increase because of assignment-of-benefit fraud that is taking place in that area,” he said. “This is a win-win for the consumer. It is a win-win for the company.”


Heritage imposed the water cap on homes in Broward, Hillsborough, Lake, Miami Dade, Orange, Osceola and Seminole counties, all counties known for high assignment-ofbenefits claims, a spokeswoman said.


Citizens, the state-owned insurance company of last resort, similarly blamed assignment of benefits at the time of its 2017 decision to raise rates and impose a $10,000 water cap on all its home policies, unless the homeowner agreed to use Citizens’ managed-repair program.


“We’re not sitting back and saying, `Hey we’ll wait until next year, and maybe we can get something done from a legislative standpoint next year,’ ” Citizens President and CEO Barry Gilway said after the Citizens’ board approved the changes. “We can’t wait. It doesn’t make any sense and we don’t know — particularly with the current structure of the Legislature — we don’t know if we’ll be any more successful next year.”


Then, in December 2022, as part of a special session devoted to insurance reform, the state Legislature finally voted to eliminate assignment of benefits.


“The historic reforms signed today create an environment which realigns Florida to best practices across the nation, adding much-needed stability to Florida’s market, promoting competition, and increasing consumer choice,” Gov. Ron DeSantis said in a statement released when he signed the bill. “I am thankful the Legislature answered the call for meaningful reform.”


Heritage later scaled back its water limit, eliminating the $10,000 cap for homes in the seven counties that had seen high claims. But the company left the cap in place statewide for houses at least 40 years old and for houses at least 30 years old that have a more limited form of insurance called dwelling fire, the spokeswoman said.


Heritage’s current CEO, Ernie Garateix, credits the state legislature’s insurance reforms with allowing the company to improve its coverage and serve a broader range of homeowners.


“The insurance reforms made in Florida in 2022 have been a major boost to our ability to write more policies and price them more affordably,” he said in a written statement. “Before the reforms, we had essentially stopped writing new policies in most parts of the state. Compare that to this year where we are up 50% in new policies just over last year. The more the market can work, the more competition is introduced and the more we are able to continue to lower prices and introduce new credits and discounts for customers.”


But at many other companies, the water damage limit has endured, according to the news organizations’ analysis of a decade of state-approved policy changes reviewed through July 2026.


Citizens spokesman Michael Peltier said his company will maintain its broad $10,000 cap despite the Legislature’s action to eliminate assignment of benefits.


“While the AOB issue has been addressed, this sublimit has become an industry norm as nonweather-related water loss claims continue to be a source of fraud and abuse,” he said in an email. “At this time, we have no plans to make changes to this language.”


The limit on water payments is especially important to insurers and homeowners because it addresses the most widespread cause of insurance claims in Florida that don’t involve hurricanes, amounting to nearly 74,000 closed claims in 2025, according to a state analysis of insurers’ reports. Burst pipes can cause extensive damage quickly, with repairs requiring workers to tear out walls, install new pipes, replace floors and ceilings and clean out mold. Such work can quickly mount into five or even six figures.


Neither the cap nor the underlying water damage coverage applies to ground level flooding from rains or high tides, which is generally covered with a separate policy.


“The cap on water damage is ridiculously low,” David Hall, a public adjuster in the Brevard County city of Palm Bay, wrote in an email. “Kitchen damage starts at a base of 20K. Add flooring, other rooms, that can go to 50k in an instant. I have done several in that price range here in Florida.”


Of the 12 companies in the news organizations’ analysis, seven have maintained $10,000 caps on water damage for at least some homes. These included American Integrity, Citizens, Florida Peninsula, Heritage, Manatee, Slide, and State Farm.


At some of these companies, the caps applied only to homes age 40 or older, which tend to have older, more fragile pipe systems. Florida has 2.5 million houses that are at least this old, representing 40% of the state’s single-family homes, according to 2026 property tax records.


And some insurers do allow homeowners to pay extra to get more water coverage. Slide, for instance, said it allows customers to choose no coverage, coverage capped at $10,000, or full coverage, with premiums adjusted according to coverage level.


In a statement, State Farm said its $10,000 water cap for older homes and other restrictions helped keep coverage costs down.


“Endorsements like this are intended to better align coverage with risk and help keep

premiums affordable for Florida customers,” the company said.


“State Farm regularly reviews and updates coverages and endorsements to provide

customers with meaningful protection and value while helping keep premiums as stable and affordable as possible.”


Mark Friedlander, spokesman for the industry-funded Insurance Information Institute, said the water cap is a common limit, and not only in Florida.


“A $10,000 water damage limit is common in home insurance policies across Florida and numerous other hurricane-prone coastal states,” he said. “This policy limit has been the norm for many Florida property/casualty insurers for more than a decade.”


“Availability of higher water damage limits varies by insurer and by the age and location of the home. Homeowners should ask their insurance professional whether a higher limit is offered, what it costs to add as an endorsement to your policy, and what inspections may be required to secure the additional coverage.”


Some companies, like Citizens, waive the limit if the policyholder agrees to participate in a managed-repair program, where the insurance company chooses the contractor, which companies say helps control costs. Such programs have become more common over the past decade, with five of the 12 companies operating them and offering policyholders incentives to sign up. But such programs can bring their own issues.


“The homeowner did not select that contractor, research the company, check references, independently verify its qualifications or workers’ compensation coverage, or compare its proposal against competing contractors,” said Brian Christensen, a public adjuster with offices in Lake Worth and Merritt Island. “If I never have to worry about getting my next job and the insurance company is dictating what the contractor does for repairs, why would I worry about the quality of my work, materials used on the job and quality employees? Then quality goes down.”


An obscure new limit harms homeowners


One common insurance limit can leave homeowners on the hook for thousands of dollars in repairs, and most policyholders are unaware of its existence.


Olympus Insurance Co. of Jacksonville applied in 2020 to state regulators, who must sign off on every policy change, for permission to limit homeowners’ coverage for what’s called “matching.” That’s coverage to make sure that repaired walls, floors, cabinets or roof sections match undamaged areas. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, often referred to as OIR, refused the company’s request, noting a state law that appeared to require insurance companies to pay to match damaged areas to undamaged areas. Olympus sued, citing the high cost of matching particularly in cases of roof damage.


“Olympus desired to set a specific maximum limit for matching because it has historically paid out large amounts in matching costs, particularly related to roof repairs and the costs paid to match roof tiles and shingles,” the company stated in a lawsuit filed in Leon County, location of Florida’s state capital and the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, “beyond coverage that was contemplated by the coverage offered by Olympus and the actuarially sound rates that Olympus is required to charge in connection with such coverage.”


So insurance regulators gave in. OIR approved a policy condition allowing the company to limit matching payments, and Olympus dropped the lawsuit.

Olympus’ program — which was soon to be copied by other insurers — limited matching to 1% of the insured value of the house. So for a house insured for $500,000, the company would pay up to $5,000 for matching.


Such a payment can be sufficient or it can be far below the tens of thousands it can cost to match parts of a home that sustained severe damage. While this may sound like a superficial concern, floors, roofs or cabinets that contain sections that don’t match can make it harder to sell a house.


Since the time Olympus imposed its matching limit, the Legislature has approved a series of limits on roof coverage in an attempt to address concerns from insurance companies. But asked recently whether the company would consider eliminating its matching restrictions in light of the reforms, the company’s chief executive officer said that it would not.


“Recent reforms, including changes to roof coverage requirements, have helped address some of the factors driving claim costs,” CEO Tim Stroble said in a written statement. “However, matching remains a broader issue that can arise across many types of property losses, not just roofing claims. The matching limitation was adopted to address situations where matching requirements led to claim payments that significantly exceeded the cost of repairing the actual damage. Olympus continues to believe the limitation is an appropriate tool for controlling claims costs and helping maintain affordable coverage for Florida homeowners.”


Once Olympus won on matching, other companies wanted in. Of the 12 insurance

companies in the Orlando Sentinel/Sun Sentinel analysis, seven adopted the 1% matching limit in a burst of copycat filings with the state after the Olympus lawsuit was resolved. These include Slide, Florida Peninsula, Heritage, Homeowners Choice, American Integrity, First Protective (which markets its insurance under the brand name Frontline), and Tower Hill Insurance Exchange.


Critics say policyholders are the ultimate losers.


“I spoke to an insured weeks ago and she had a water loss in her kitchen and it caused damage to her kitchen cabinets and to her flooring and she got an estimate from a contractor saying it was going to cost her over $100,000 to put her home back to its pre-loss condition,” said Dean Makris, a Tampa lawyer who represents homeowners. “Well, the insurance company applied a 1% matching limitation and that dropped her coverage down to about $3,800.”


Another policy restriction few know about until they encounter it concerns appraisals. These are estimates from independent experts, used when the insurance company and the policyholder disagree on the cost of repairs. Five of the 12 companies in the news organizations’ analysis have restricted the right to appraisal over the past eight years — First Protective, Heritage, State Farm, Tower Hill and Universal.


Separate appraisals can help break impasses that would otherwise lead to a homeowner filing suit or paying for much of the damage themselves, said Christensen, the public adjuster.


At a house damaged by fire in Lake County, he said, the insurance company offered $147,000. His client was able to bring in an independent appraiser to the site, whose report persuaded the company to pay more than $300,000, a huge difference to the homeowner and a result that avoided going to court.


“There were two of us that have been in the industry and no construction,” Christensen said. “We’re able to settle it. Just me and the appraiser.”


Some companies with appraisal restrictions say they will allow the homeowner to get one with the company’s permission, but Christensen said he has never seen a company approve a homeowner’s request for an independent appraisal.


“Same response every single time: ‘We do not agree,’ ” he said in an email. “That is it! No explanation why.”


In an interview in July, the Sentinel and Sun Sentinel asked Florida Insurance

Commissioner Mike Yaworsky whether the state should consider rescinding some of the limitations on water coverage, matching and other protections that arose in 2022 and earlier in light of the state’s subsequent legislative reforms on behalf of insurance

companies.


“That’s a really good question, and I think that is something that as the market continues and as we can show that it’s sustainable, I think that that is something that actually we’ve talked about,” Yaworsky said. “We need to look at what was allowed during that dark time to start pulling that back.”


But he said it was important to not declare victory prematurely and risk disturbing the

insurance market’s recovery.


“I’m really focused on we’ve had three crises in Florida since (Hurricane) Andrew in the insurance space,” he said. “I’m really focused on sustainability and hopefully making this the last one that we had to go through.”


There are some recent indications that Florida’s improved insurance market could lead the companies themselves to pare back limits as they compete for business.


Brian Samberg, senior vice president of NSI Insurance Group of Miami, which sells insurance provided by other companies, said he has seen insurers starting to remove the $10,000 water limit from their policies. Thanks to legislative reforms intended to prevent lawsuits and inflated bills, he said, insurance companies are less concerned about being hit with inflated claims for damages.


“We’re seeing those sublimits in many cases disappear,” he said. “They’re not fearful now that it’s going to be $100,000, so they’re more comfortable taking on more exposure.”


But Elliott, the spokeswoman for the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, said the agency has not heard recently of any companies making such moves.


“The $10,000 water damage limit has actually been around for quite a while, and we aren’t aware of any carriers eliminating that limit or the matching limit over the past year,” she said.


In fact, only a few of the companies in the news organizations’ analysis have resisted the appeal of the coverage limits. Universal Property and Casualty Insurance Co., based in Fort Lauderdale, is one: It does not impose a restriction on matching payments or a water cap, though it has limited appraisals.


Universal “has not adopted the types of mandated coverage reductions that became

prevalent in the Florida market in recent years, including mandatory water damage

restrictions or matching limits,” said Travis Miller, a lawyer who spoke for the company. “One significant distinction for UPCIC is that the company generally maintained the core coverages available under its homeowners products during Florida’s challenging pre-reform years. UPCIC’s approach throughout this time was to continue offering policyholders and agents consistent, predictable coverage despite the challenges facing the market.”


Fine print and exceptions


Many homeowners think they have a copy of their insurance policy. But they may be

wrong.


Insurance companies often provide only the first few pages, which lay out the basics of the homeowner’s coverage. The full policy can be obtained only by requesting it from the company.


But if you do ask for it, what you’ll receive are 70 or so pages of dense text written by lawyers that’s difficult for non-experts to understand.


Much of the language comes from a national model, which is why many policies offer

protection against hazards that may not seem particularly relevant in Florida. (“All volcanic eruptions that occur within any 168-hour period will be considered one volcanic eruption,” notes the State Farm policy of an Orlando homeowner.)


Diane Albin, head of her neighborhood association in Vero Beach, said that when she

shopped around for insurance she found the policy language baffling, full of exceptions and limits to situations that were so poorly described she didn’t understand what coverage was being offered and what was being restricted.


“I also started reading some fine print and there’s more caveats, as as the insurance rates were going up, the deduction, the deductible and all that kind of stuff was also ‘Well, this isn’t covered, and we’re only going to cover this up to 300,000 and this and that,’ ” she said. “You have to be a lawyer to understand all that language.”


A survey of 1,511 homeowners conducted this summer by the Orlando Sentinel, South Florida Sun Sentinel and University of North Florida’s Public Opinion Research Lab found that just 30% of homeowners claimed to “fully understand” their insurance policies. The number saying they had a “basic understanding” was 60%.


Despite state rules requiring companies to highlight in plain language major points such as coverage limits and deductibles, insurance policies are full of paragraphs such as this from the American Integrity policy of a woman in the Tampa suburb of Brandon:


“2. Excluded under SECTION I — EXCLUSIONS.


Under items 1. and 2. any ensuing loss to property described in COVERAGE A — Dwelling and COVERAGE B — Other Structures not excluded or excepted in this policy is covered.


Section I-Exclusion 1.c.Water Damage, paragraphs (1) and (4) that apply to surface water and water below the surface of the ground do not apply to loss by water covered under 1.b. (6) and (7) above.”


A lack of clarity in policies can mean many homeowners don’t know what’s covered and what’s not until a pipe bursts or a hurricane damages their roof.


“Insurance policies are not easy to read,” said Charles Nyce, a professor and insurance expert at Florida State University’s College of Business. “They are legal documents. They are written the way they are because of numerous lawsuits and claims and cases that have generated the way the standard language has to be established today. So no, I don’t think people really understand what they’re purchasing, and I don’t think that they understand what’s covered and what’s not covered.”


In addition, policies tempt homeowners with chances to save money that could turn out to be disastrous. Insurance companies often offer optional limits on coverage, such as higher deductibles or dollar-amount coverage caps for particular hazards, in return for a lower premium. Although this can make insurance more affordable, consumer advocates say many people may not understand the significance of the protection they’re giving up.


For example, nine of the 12 insurance companies in the news organizations’ review have received permission from the state to offer homeowners a discount if the customer agreed to reduced roof coverage based on age and materials. The company would pay the full replacement cost for a new roof, for example, but a lower amount, such as 25% of the replacement cost, for a 20-year-old shingle roof.


In insurance terms, this means paying the roof’s “actual cash value” — what it’s worth

considering its age and materials — rather than its “replacement cost,” which would mean buying the homeowner a new roof. State law requires insurers to offer replacement cost coverage, but they are free to charge more for that coverage.


Opting for such a restriction in coverage can save homeowners money on the premiums but prove costly if they ever need to file a claim. Depending on the size of the house, a new roof can cost $20,000 or $30,000.


“They’re trying to save money on their premiums and they have no idea what they’re

buying,” said Gina Clausen Lozier, a Greenacres lawyer who represents homeowners. “You’re spending thousands and thousands of dollars to insure your most expensive asset, your home, and you have no idea what you’re purchasing.

And so you may be saving $300 on your premium, but you just walked yourself out of coverage for your roof entirely.”


“I’ve been doing this for 20 years,” she said. “I have my master’s in insurance and risk management. So I’m good at reading policies because I’ve learned the language. It’s a different language — it’s covered and then it’s excluded and then there’s an exception to the coverage, so it comes in, it comes out, it comes back in but limited. It’s just impossible to understand.”


Insurance companies consider such limitations in roof coverage to be fair, since roofs can deteriorate considerably over the years, and it’s not the function of insurance to pay for a home’s routine maintenance.


“Homeowners insurance is designed to cover sudden and accidental damage, not serve as a maintenance or warranty plan for normal aging and wear and tear,” said Karen Collins, vice president of personal lines of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association, in a statement. “Actual cash value and other roof coverage options recognize depreciation while continuing to provide protection for covered storm damage. Offering different coverage options can help consumers balance the protection they want with the premium they pay.”


State regulators greenlight insurance company requests


The agency that stands between homeowners and their insurance companies is the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.


Any time an insurance company wants to change the coverage provided by its standard policy contracts, it has to obtain that agency’s permission. But approval rates are high. Like many states, Florida designates filings as approved after a certain period of time, 30 days in Florida’s case, if the agency hadn’t taken any action.


An analysis conducted by the University of Maryland’s Howard Center for Investigative Journalism found that the agency approved the vast majority of filings for the 12 tracked companies. And the companies’ success has increased markedly over the past few years.


From 2016 to 2020, the agency approved 76% of these filings, with the Howard Center’s review indicating that many filings were withdrawn after OIR raised concerns. For the period 2021 to 2025, the approval rate increased to 95%, according to the analysis.


Laura Youmans, legislative affairs director for the Florida Justice Association, which

represents trial lawyers, reviewed the news organizations’ analysis and said she believes the high approval percentages reflect OIR’s overriding interest in protecting the industry.


“Keeping carriers solvent seems to have become the priority instead of consumer

protection and transparency,” she said.


“My read is that the rise in filings reflects a push to give insurers more favorable policy terms as a way to keep them out of insolvency and improve profitability,” she continued. “The industry will likely say the filings were needed to carry out the legal reforms the Legislature passed.”


“But during the same period, OIR also approved many policy changes that narrowed what insurers have to cover. I suspect those coverage reductions, together with better global insurance market conditions, have done more to restore insurer profitability than the legal changes have.”


But OIR spokeswoman Elliott said the increase in approvals reflects the agency’s

collaborative approach, rather than leniency.


“As for our internal review process, the increase in form approval rates doesn’t mean our level of scrutiny has decreased,” she said in an email. “Our analysts routinely work directly with companies during the review process to amend language or provisions or have the carrier withdraw the filing altogether, rather than letting those filings go all the way to a formal disapproval.”


The starting point for the Howard Center’s analysis of those filings was the Office of

Insurance Regulation’s website, which maintains a public database of these documents, submitted by insurance companies seeking to change their rates, alter coverage or make minor adjustments to their policy forms. A link to the system appears under the heading “Consumer Resources,” which the agency provides “to help consumers navigate insurance and make better informed decisions.”


But the system is difficult to use. What is available to the public can be accessed only

through a cumbersome process that requires the consumer to submit a request for each individual filing and wait for the document to be delivered by email.


Many documents are simply blocked from public view. The number of filings with at least one document stamped “trade secret” has increased sharply for the top 12 companies, rising from zero in 2020 to 52.6% so far in 2026, according to the analysis. In most cases journalists were able to ascertain what was being proposed and approved from related documents that remained public.


OIR spokeswoman Elliott said the increase in documents designated trade secrets was the direct result of a statutory change that gave companies greater power to place that restriction on their own filings. The 2021 Florida law exempted such trade secrets, which were broadly defined, from the state’s public records law and applied to all state agencies.


“Because companies are exercising rights granted under Florida law, changing whether or not they can mark those filings as trade secrets would require legislative action, not an internal change within the OIR,” Elliott said.


Nevertheless, the agency retains significant power over the quality of insurance policies. In 2022, for example, after the state Legislature rejected a series of insurance changes supported by the industry, OIR stepped in and gave insurance companies permission to adopt some of them through the regulatory process.


The moves were approved under then-OIR chief David Altmaier, who left the Office of

Insurance Regulation later that year and a few months later joined the lobbying firm The Southern Group, where today he represents insurance companies. The state’s insurance office is now headed by Yaworsky, a lawyer who has led the agency since shortly after Altmaier’s departure.


Among the 2022 changes were measures addressing what had been seen as a crisis in roof claims, when insurance companies said rogue contractors were persuading homeowners to file questionable damage claims to justify getting brand-new roofs.


To fight this, OIR began explicitly allowing insurers to offer homeowners the option of

reduced roof coverage in exchange for lower premiums — instituting separate roof

deductibles and broadly endorsing the “actual cash value” approach in which

reimbursement for damage declined as the roof aged.


Even though insurers were still required to offer full replacement coverage as well, the move drew some criticism.


“The Florida legislature considered whether we would provide a cap on roofs, and they said, ‘No, we’re not going to do that. We’re not going to pass that,’ ” said Amy Boggs, a St. Petersburg lawyer who represents homeowners against insurance companies.


“Meanwhile, . . . the carriers were putting through policy endorsements that limited the coverage. And our insurance regulator, Altmaier, at the time accepted that and said, ‘Okay, we’re going to allow that provision in the policy.’ ”

But even critics who view the agency as biased toward insurance companies say it is not a rubber stamp.


“As far as the policy review goes, there were several places where OIR did push back on some of the policy form changes,” said Youmans of the Florida Justice Association. “But because of the way that the statutes authorize OIR, they’re just kind of set up to allow for more deference to the industry. And ultimately most of the policy changes that the industry requested were approved.”


Although many observers saw the agency as particularly industry-friendly under Altmaier, they said it still shows excessive deference toward companies whose presence and financial health is essential to the state’s prosperity. As Florida’s insurance regulators have tried to coax insurance companies into reentering the state, often relying on small, non-name brand companies, they have tried to create conditions in which they could do well in a market dominated by the threat of hurricanes.


“It’s put the state in a position where they’re trying to defend them, protect this very weak structure that they themselves created,” said Martin Weiss, founder of Weiss Ratings, which assesses the financial health of insurance companies and other institutions. “And that leads to a tendency to go easy on these companies who came to the state on their invitation, and under-regulate, give them a protected environment, protected by the state from their customers.”


‘Upon reviewing your policy, we are unable to afford coverage…’


Insurance companies argue that the ability to offer less generous coverage allows them to provide affordable insurance in one of the most disaster-prone parts of the United States. Consumer advocates denounce that claim as a smokescreen for a successful attempt by the industry to protect profits, not only by increasing premiums but by the stealthier method of reducing coverage.


“In the long run it has the same effect, and it’s much subtler, which makes it easier

politically for them to enact,” said Doug Heller, director of insurance for the Consumer

Federation of America. “Where this turns from just angering to tragic is when people

discover that they’ve purchased a junk insurance policy, in that moment in their life when they need to rely on that policy. That’s when this stops. That’s when people will be really angry.”


Although such reductions in coverage have happened in other states, Florida has been at the forefront, he said.


“Florida has been a place for this kind of ugly innovation in this business,” he said. “But we see this around the country.”


Whatever the case, there’s no question that Florida homeowners have insurance policies locked away in filing cabinets and saved on their computers that offer much less protection than they think.


Consider the case of Chad Romano of Coral Springs, whose moment of revelation came after his daughter noticed the wood floor of their home appeared to be wavy.


It turned out there was a leaking pipe under their house, a mishap that would require them to tear out and replace their kitchen floor, counters and cabinets.


Slide Insurance of Tampa, which had scooped up the Romanos’ business after they were dumped by Citizens, told them they had a hard coverage limit of $10,000 for mold and $10,000 for water.


The company would not cover water damage beyond those limits, nor would it pay to fix the leaky pipe itself.


“Upon reviewing your policy, we are unable to afford coverage for the portion of your loss related to the faulty plumbing,” stated a letter from Slide. “The damages associated with the faulty pipe are not covered due to it being considered standard wear and tear.”


Romano and his wife had to borrow money from his father and take out a home equity loan, going into their own pockets for about $27,500 to repair the pipe and the rest of the damage.


“I said, Well, wait a minute. We’ve paid you, I don’t know, 30, 40, 50,000 dollars over the course of two or three years,” he said. “And you’re telling me you’re only going to cover up to 20? Well, yeah. Per the state of Florida, blah blah blah, you only get 10,000 for mold and remediation and then 10,000 for water damage.”


In a statement about its coverage in general, not referring to this particular case, Slide said it does not impose a universal $10,000 cap on water damage but rather lets customers choose between no coverage, coverage capped at $10,000 or full coverage. Customers who opt for less coverage pay lower premiums.


Until he experienced the leak, Romano said, he had no idea he faced a $10,000 water cap.


“Honestly, maybe that was my fault that I didn’t go and take a magnifying glass to every single line item that’s on the insurance,” he said. “I mean, realistically, who does that?”


Sammy Liu of the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism and data journalist Patrick McCaslin contributed data analysis for this story.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page