Future Broward commuter rail link gets $164M grant but faces hurdles
In late October, shortly before the mid-term elections, the Federal Transit Administration delivered a major lift to Broward County’s long-standing ambitions for a new coastal commuter rail link along the Florida East Coast Railway line.
The agency, which is part of the U.S. Department of Transportation, awarded a $164 million grant to jumpstart the Broward County Commuter Rail South project, whose capital costs currently stand at $712 million, with other funding sources to be determined.
The local commuter trains could start running in 2032 between Fort Lauderdale and Aventura, connecting to Miami-Dade County’s planned Northeast Corridor commuter project, Coree Cuff Lonergan, the head of Broward County Transit, said.
After years of state and local agency planning, as well as debates and quests for funding, the federal grant is regarded among government officials as a watershed moment toward creating a commuter rail system that could move more motorists off South Florida’s crowded roadways as the combined population of Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties moves well past 6 million.
The Broward project is an offshoot of a so-called “Coastal Link” project that emerged in the early 2000s from the drawing boards of the Florida Department of Transportation. The vision at the time was to provide an 85-mile commuter rail service along the Florida East Coast Railway line on the east side of each county from Miami to Jupiter. Since then, planning has focused on segments in Miami-Dade and Broward.
The idea gained traction after Brightline inaugurated service in 2018 along the FEC line between Miami and West Palm Beach. Originally intended as a high-speed inter-city line, not a commuter line, Brightline opened its extension to Orlando in September 2023.
Along the way, Brightline entered into talks with Miami-Dade and Broward counties about essentially sub-letting its excess capacity along the FEC line for a commuter service under the Coastal Rail Link moniker. Formal operating agreements between each county and Brightline, which are still pending, would result in each county paying millions in access rights to Brightline.
Coree Cuff Lonergan is CEO and general manager of Broward County Transit, which would work in concert with Miami-Dade to operate a new commuter service that would run from a point south of the New River in Fort Lauderdale to downtown Miami.
“I would characterize it more as an extension of the Miami project,” she said in a recent interview of the proposed Broward County South rail portion.
The 10.5-mile Broward link supported by the grant would start in Aventura, run north through new stations in Hollywood and Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport, and end in a neighborhood that includes the Broward Health Medical Center between 15th and 17th streets in Fort Lauderdale.
“The Broward County Commuter Rail South project will improve transportation options for families and commuters between Miami and Fort Lauderdale,” said FTA Acting Deputy Administrator Matthew Cahill in a statement. “Transportation and mobility are all about improving the functionality of cities. This project will help connect South Floridians to essential services such as healthcare, education and employment centers.”
But for now, the coastal line would stop short of the New River crossing in downtown Fort Lauderdale as Broward County and city officials have failed to agree on whether to construct a new bridge or a tunnel to accommodate the additional rail traffic the coastal link would bring.
Officials in Oakland Park, Pompano Beach and Deerfield Beach have all expressed interest in the new line serving their cities, which are north of the river.
The FTA did not respond to a question about why the federal government chose to fund another rail project in an area already served by Brightline and Tri-Rail. The Broward grant, according to local government officials, was only one of two awarded by the FTA this year; the other was a $1.28 billion outlay for a commuter rail system in Utah.
For more than 30 years, Tri-Rail’s commuter trains have lumbered up and down a state-owned rail line that runs mostly west of I-95 between a point north of West Palm Beach, through Broward County and into terminus destinations that include downtown Miami and Miami International Airport. The rail corridor is also used by the CSX freight line and the Amtrak national passenger rail service.
A Brightline train traverses the railroad bridge over the New River in downtown Fort Lauderdale on Monday. Fort Lauderdale has been pushing for a new train tunnel to be built, but some doubt it will ever happen. (Joe Cavaretta/South Florida Sun Sentinel)
The proposed Broward Coastal Rail Link project would stop at a point south of the New River rail crossing in downtown Fort Lauderdale as city and Broward County officials have failed to agree on whether to build a new bridge or a tunnel to accommodate additional rail traffic a new commuter line would bring to the Florida East Coast Railway corridor. (Joe Cavaretta South Florida Sun Sentinel)
Demand for passenger rail
Both Brightline and Tri-Rail have amply demonstrated that there is a significant demand among South Florida travelers for local and regional rail transportation.
It’s an area whose major north-south highways — I-95 and Florida’s Turnpike — are choked daily with commuter traffic despite repeated widening projects and fast-lane installations over the years.
Last year, according to passenger ridership reports, the two rail lines — Tri-Rail operating along a corridor mostly west of I-95 and Brightline, operating along the Florida East Coast Railway corridor — carried more than 7 million travelers combined.
Cuff Lonergan, in an interview, said a survey conducted by the county demonstrated the coastal rail link could generate around 1.2 million “passenger trips” in its first year of operation in 2032, growing to 1.6 million by 2035.
“People who live on the beach side or the east side of I-95 are hesitant to travel across county to go south” aboard Tri-Rail to Miami-Dade, she said. “If I’m going to drive that far I’m going to drive all the way.”
“We’re fortunate to be situated along Dixie Highway and that traffic around Dixie and I-95 is pretty substantial,” she said. “That’s our sweet spot. They are not necessarily in conflict,” she said of the proposed commuter line and Tri-Rail. “The way to look at it is it will provide an additional mobility option.”
Challenges
Despite the FTA funding commitment, which still needs to be approved by Congress, according to one lawmaker, the Coastal Link still faces several hurdles.
They include a state court lawsuit brought in 2025 by the Florida East Coast Railway, owner of the rail corridor, against Brightline.
According to a harshly worded complaint, Brightline violated its operating agreement with the FEC by entering into discussions with the counties to develop the coastal commuter line. The suit, filed in 2025, has been moved into arbitration with no indication of any impending outcome.
But the court, citing inactivity in the case, has filed a motion to dismiss. And Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Robert Watson has scheduled a hearing for mid-January, according to the case file.
Cuff Lonergan acknowledged that talks between Brightline and Broward about a prospective operating agreement have slowed.
“I think what would be a fair statement is we’ve slowed down the conversation as we await the outcome of the litigation,” she said.
In Miami-Dade, County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava reportedly has raised objections about the county’s proposed Coastal Link agreement with Brightline, saying it is not entirely in the best interests of county taxpayers. The mayor wants to reach an agreement with Brightline that brings commuter rail service to “our residents while protecting taxpayers. The agreement as currently proposed does not meet that standard, but she remains committed to working with Brightline to reach a deal that does,” according to a statement from the mayor’s office.
“I don’t really know all of the details of what Mayor Levine Cava may be talking about,” Cuff Lonergan said. “Obviously we all want to get the best deal for taxpayers.”
“Miami-Dade is slightly ahead of us in terms of their project,” she added. “We are not going to accept a deal that would be disadvantageous to us and would put the project at risk.”
Meanwhile, Brightline, despite industrywide plaudits as a pioneering high-speed rail project, has wracked up sizable losses as its operations have failed to keep pace with billions in debt obligations.
In October, multiple affiliates entered into restructuring agreements via Chapter 11 filings in a U.S. Bankruptcy Court in New Jersey.
Brightline’s operating arm — Brightline Trains Florida — was not among some 17 entities filing Chapter 11 petitions. But the railroad itself is receiving fresh capital, company officials have said, and Brightline’s service is continuing without interruption.
The obstacles aside, Cuff Lonergan said the coastal link’s objective would be to make commuter rail service “affordable” from a pricing standpoint, meaning it would be more accessible than Brightline higher-speed, upper-level onboard service between South Florida and Orlando. In the tri-county region, the Miami-based railroad’s trains serve Miami, Aventura, Fort Lauderdale, Boca Raton and West Palm Beach.
In its most recent ridership report, which was released in September, Brightline said its one-way short haul fares averaged $25.88. Long-haul rides to Orlando over the 235-mile line averaged $74.20.
Tri-Rail, the publicly subsidized commuter line funded by the state and the three counties it serves, raised its fares by 10% earlier this year, but they are still far lower than Brightline tickets.
“The (Coastal Link) price point will be reasonable and it is a different type of service,” Cuff Lonergan said. “Brightline is an inter-city service. Their target is someone traveling from Miami to Orlando. To be competitive with the airlines they can’t have many stops.”
Overall, she is maintaining a positive outlook. The county, she said, is “closer than ever” since people started discussing the idea more than 20 years ago.
“We are optimistically targeting the 2032 date for our opening.”



Comments